SR.NO |
COMPARISON PARAMETERS |
ZINCALUM STEEL WATER STORAGE TANKS |
CONCRETE WATER TANKS |
1 |
EXPECTED LIFE |
50 TO 60 YEARS |
20 YEARS |
2 |
WATER LEAKAGE |
ZERO LEAKAGE OR WASTAGE. |
SIGNIFICANT WATER LOSS DUE TO CRACKS. |
3 |
COST OF CONSTRUCTION |
ECONOMICAL (1/6TH TO 1/10TH THE PRICE OF EQUAL CAPACITY CONCRETE TANK) |
EXPENSIVE |
4 |
INSTALLATION TIME |
500,000 LITER STEEL TANK NEEDS 7 DAYS TO BE MANUFACTURED 5 DAYS TO BE INSTALLED. |
500,000 LITER CONCRETE TANK NEEDS 60TO
80 DAYS FOR CONSTRUCTION AND CURING.
|
5 |
CIVIL FOUNDATION |
LIGHT WEIGHT TANKS, CAN BE PLACED EASILY AS OVERHEAD TANKS, ON ROOF, IN THE BASEMENT OR UNDERGROUND ON SIMPLE AND ECONOMICAL RING BEAM FOUNDATION. |
EXPENSIVE AND TIME-CONSUMINGCIVIL FOUNDATION. |
6 |
LABOUR COST |
ONE SUPERVISOR AND 6 UNSKILLED
LABOR CAN INSTALL A 500,000 LITER STEEL TANK IN 5 DAYS.
|
LARGE TEAM OF LABORS REQUIRED FOR APPROXIMATELY 60 TO 80 DAYS. |
7 |
TRANSPORTATION COST |
ECONOMICAL DUE TO LIGHT WEIGHT AND MODULAR / BOLTED STRUCTURE. |
NOT APPLICABLE, ALTHOUGH RAW MATERIAL TRANSPORTATION ATTRACTS SIGNIFICANT COST. |
8 |
MAINTENANCE / REPAIR |
EASILY REPAIRABLE, MODULAR/ BOLTED STRUCTURE. |
DIFFICULT TO REPAIR CONCRETE CRACKS, INEEFCTIVE. |
9 |
RELOCATION |
CAN BE RELOCATED / SHIPPED EASILY IN TERMS OF STEEL SHEETS AFTER UNBOLTING. |
RELOCATION IS NOT POSSIBLE. |
10 |
FLEXIBLE CAPACITY |
CAPACITY CAN BE INCREASED OR DECREASED AT ANY POINT OF TIME EASILY, DUE TO MODULAR / BOLTED STRUCTURE. |
DIFFICULT TO INCREASE OR DECREASE CAPACITY. |
11 |
RETURN ON INVESTMENTIF SCRAPPED |
IF SCRAPED, HAS RETURN VALUE ON STEEL OR CAN BE RE-SOLD. |
NO RETURN VALUE ON SCRAP, CAN’T BERE- SOLD. ATTRACTS EXTRA COST TO BE SCRAPPED. |
12 |
STRUCTURE |
HIGH TENSILE STEEL STRUCTURE FITTED WITH PVC/EPDM INSIDE LINER/MEMBRANE, WATER AND STEEL HAVE NO DIRECT CONTACT.
|
HEAVY CONCRETE STRUCTURE AND WATER AND CONCRETE WALL HAVE DIRECT CONTACT. |
13 |
CONTAMINATION |
NO CHANCE OF CONTAMINATION, WATER IS STORED INSIDE EPDM/FOOD GRADE CHEMICALLY STABILIZED LINER, WATER AND STEEL HAVE NO DIRECT CONTACT.
|
HIGH CHANCE OF CONTAMINATION, WATER AND CONCRETE WALL HAVE DIRECT CONTACT. |
14 |
DAMAGE / CRACKS |
MOVEMENT OF HEAVY VEHICLE NEREBY OR EARTH MOVEMENT MAKES NO DAMAGE. |
MOVEMENT OF HEAVY VEHICLE NEREBYOR EARTH MOVEMENT MAKES CRACKS. |
15 |
VARIABLE PROJECT COST |
SUPPLY ON PRE-DECIDED COST |
LONG CONSTRUCTION TIME, WEATHER, INCONVENIENT CONSTRUCTION AREA INFLUENCE THE COST. |